Evaluating Alternative Harvest Control Rules for New England Groundfish
Identifying the most robust harvest control rules.
The New England Fishery Management Council (NEFMC) initiated a groundfish harvest control rule review so that fishery management can be sure they are prescribing the actions that are best suited for their respective fisheries and stocks, with the goal of improving groundfish management. We propose to use a management strategy evaluation (MSE) model framework to simulation test the performance of a range of alternative harvest control rules for the groundfish fishery and identify best practices in support of the NEFMC effort.
- Develop of a suite of groundfish operating models that span a range of conditions.
- Generate retrospective patterns through the mis-specification of operating and estimation models.
- Design and simulation test alternative harvest control rules.
- Provide information that can help managers evaluate tradeoffs and identify harvest control rules that are robust to a range of uncertainties.
A harvest control rule is a prescribed management action developed in response to stock status assessments. The New England Fishery Management Council (NEFMC) manages groundfish stocks through the Northeast multispecies groundfish fishery management plan (FMP). That plan defines the harvest control rule used to determine the Acceptable Biological Catch (ABC) for each groundfish stock. Because the harvest control rules result from stock assessments, it's crucial that these assessments are accurate, but updated retrospective stock estimates have generated a level of uncertainty in the assessment process that have put the current harvest control rule, implemented in 2010 through Amendment 16, into question.
Additionally, the current harvest control rules in place, as well as any alternatives, have not been simulation tested. This, combined with policy and management applications since 2010 suggest that the current harvest control rules should be reevaluated to determine if they are still consistent with best practices.
In response to the issues emerging about current harvest control rules, the NEFMC has initiated a groundfish harvest control rule review so that fisheries management can be sure they are prescribing the actions that are best for their respective fisheries and stocks.
We used a management strategy evaluation (MSE) model framework to simulation test a range of alternative harvest control rule performances within the groundfish fishery. Through an MSE approach, we used simulation modeling to test the performance of alternative fisheries management procedures by developing models of the entire fishery resource system — including the fish, fishery, stock assessment, and management process. This will help us to identify possible outcomes and tradeoffs of current and alternative harvest control rules before we actually implement them on the water. MSE is a powerful tool for developing management strategies for fishery resources that are robust to uncertainties about the fish-fishery-management system.
Our final report includes findings on how alternative HCRs performed in various scenarios, including when stocks are overfished compared to not overfished.
Lisa Kerr, Ph.D.
Associate Professor, UMaine School of Marine Sciences; Senior Research Scientist, GMRI[email protected]
Steven Cadrin, Ph.D.
University of Dartmouth
Mackenzie Mazur, Ph.D.
Postdoctoral Research Associate[email protected]
Quantitative Research Associate[email protected]
This project is generously supported by the New England Fisheries Management Council (NEFMC).
Women in Climate and Fisheries: A Just Transition to a Sustainable Future
GMRI Quantitative Research Associate Carly Lovas reflects on a workshop she organized for the fifth annual Sustainable Development Goals conference in Bergen, Norway, called Women …
2022 Sustainable Seafood Impact Report
We want to keep you updated on our sustainable seafood team's progress, so we've developed a report showcasing some of their biggest achievements from 2022.
Gulf of Maine Warming Update: 2022 the Second-Hottest Year on Record
Over the past decade, scientists at the Gulf of Maine Research Institute have led a body of research that highlights the rapid pace of warming …
2022 Gulf of Maine Ventures Impact Report
Gulf of Maine Ventures is the growing business development and impact investment arm of GMRI. In 2022, we've made huge progress, continuing to grow the …